TY - JOUR
T1 - Visual statistical learning is facilitated in Zipfian distributions
AU - Lavi-Rotbain, Ori
AU - Arnon, Inbal
N1 - Funding Information: We thank Alen Viner for help with analyzing the database of visual objects. We thank Zohar Aizenbud for help with preparing the study. We thank Ephrat Simhon and Shmuel Haikin for their help in collecting the data. We thank Noam Siegelman and Shira Tal for feedback on previous versions of the paper. We thank the Living Lab staff and the Bloomfield Science Museum in Jerusalem, as well as the parents and children who participated. The research was funded by the Israeli Science Foundation grant number 584/16 awarded to the second author. Funding Information: We thank Alen Viner for help with analyzing the database of visual objects. We thank Zohar Aizenbud for help with preparing the study. We thank Ephrat Simhon and Shmuel Haikin for their help in collecting the data. We thank Noam Siegelman and Shira Tal for feedback on previous versions of the paper. We thank the Living Lab staff and the Bloomfield Science Museum in Jerusalem, as well as the parents and children who participated. The research was funded by the Israeli Science Foundation grant number 584/16 awarded to the second author. Publisher Copyright: © 2020 Elsevier B.V.
PY - 2021/1
Y1 - 2021/1
N2 - Humans can extract co-occurrence regularities from their environment, and use them for learning. This statistical learning ability (SL) has been studied extensively as a way to explain how we learn the structure of our environment. These investigations have illustrated the impact of various distributional properties on learning. However, almost all SL studies present the regularities to be learned in uniform frequency distributions where each unit (e.g., image triplet) appears the same number of times: While the regularities themselves are informative, the appearance of the units cannot be predicted. In contrast, real-world learning environments, including the words children hear and the objects they see, are not uniform. Recent research shows that word segmentation is facilitated in a skewed (Zipfian) distribution. Here, we examine the domain-generality of the effect and ask if visual SL is also facilitated in a Zipfian distribution. We use an existing database to show that object combinations have a skewed distribution in children's environment. We then show that children and adults showed better learning in a Zipfian distribution compared to a uniform one, overall, and for low-frequency triplets. These results illustrate the facilitative impact of skewed distributions on learning across modality and age; suggest that the use of uniform distributions may underestimate performance; and point to the possible learnability advantage of such distributions in the real-world.
AB - Humans can extract co-occurrence regularities from their environment, and use them for learning. This statistical learning ability (SL) has been studied extensively as a way to explain how we learn the structure of our environment. These investigations have illustrated the impact of various distributional properties on learning. However, almost all SL studies present the regularities to be learned in uniform frequency distributions where each unit (e.g., image triplet) appears the same number of times: While the regularities themselves are informative, the appearance of the units cannot be predicted. In contrast, real-world learning environments, including the words children hear and the objects they see, are not uniform. Recent research shows that word segmentation is facilitated in a skewed (Zipfian) distribution. Here, we examine the domain-generality of the effect and ask if visual SL is also facilitated in a Zipfian distribution. We use an existing database to show that object combinations have a skewed distribution in children's environment. We then show that children and adults showed better learning in a Zipfian distribution compared to a uniform one, overall, and for low-frequency triplets. These results illustrate the facilitative impact of skewed distributions on learning across modality and age; suggest that the use of uniform distributions may underestimate performance; and point to the possible learnability advantage of such distributions in the real-world.
KW - Domain-general
KW - Information theory
KW - Learning
KW - Predictability
KW - Visual statistical learning
KW - Zipfian distribution
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85096199288&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2020.104492
DO - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2020.104492
M3 - Article
C2 - 33157380
SN - 0010-0277
VL - 206
JO - Cognition
JF - Cognition
M1 - 104492
ER -