Iron (oxyhydr)oxides shift the methanogenic community in deep sea methanic sediment - insights from long-term high-pressure incubations

Intermittent increases of dissolved ferrous iron concentrations have been observed in deep marine methanic sediments which is different from the traditional diagenetic electron acceptor cascade, where iron reduction precedes methanogenesis. Here we aimed to gain insight into the mechanism of iron reduction and the associated microbial processes in deep sea methanic sediment by setting up long-term high-pressure incubation experiments supplemented with ferrihydrite and methane. Continuous iron reduction was observed during the entire incubation period. Intriguingly, ferrihydrite addition shifted the archaeal community from the dominance of hydrogenotrophic methanogens (Methanogenium) to methylotrophic methanogens (Methanococcoides). The enriched samples were then amended with ¹³C-labeled methane and different iron (oxyhydr)oxides in batch slurries to test the mechanism of iron reduction. Intensive iron reduction was observed, the highest rates with ferrihydrite, followed by hematite and then magnetite, however, no anaerobic oxidation of methane (AOM) was observed in any treatment. Further tests on the enriched slurry showed that the addition of molybdate decreased iron reduction, suggesting a link between iron reduction with sulfur cycling. This was accompanied by the enrichment of microbes capable of dissimilatory sulfate reduction and sulfur/thiosulfate oxidation, which indicates the presence of a cryptic sulfur cycle in the incubation system with the addition of iron (oxyhydr)oxides. Our work suggests that under low sulfate conditions, the presence of iron (oxyhydr)oxides would trigger a cascade of microbial reactions, and iron reduction could link with the microbial sulfur cycle, changing the kinetics of the methanogenesis process in methanic sediment.