Abstract
In this chapter, we develop a comprehensive typology, alongside measurements of personalism and collegialism, of cabinets and governments in democracies. The scholarly literature identifies and addresses the personal and collegial elements within governments in democracies, but falls short of proposing a comprehensive typology and compatible measurements. We present what we call the Cabinet-Government Model, which includes two perspectives: a narrow one that focuses on the cabinet and a wider one that also relates to the interaction of the cabinet with other political institutions (parliament, election, bureaucracy, party) and thus refers to the government as a whole. After listing the ideal types of collegial and personal governments, we chart its measurements. We then analyze 28 democratic governments using materials from various databases and constitutional sources. The analysis identifies a high level of variation in personalism between cabinets and governments throughout the democratic world, demonstrates that a focus on the cabinet alone is not sufficient for capturing levels of personalism of governments, and paints a more nuanced picture than the hitherto-simple categorization of parliamentary, presidential, and semi-presidential governments.
Original language | English |
---|---|
Title of host publication | Collegial Democracy versus Personal Democracy |
Subtitle of host publication | ‘We’ the People or ‘I’ the People? |
Pages | 87-105 |
Number of pages | 19 |
ISBN (Electronic) | 9781040003053 |
DOIs | |
State | Published - 1 Jan 2024 |
All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes
- General Social Sciences