Antibiotics Interfere with the Evolution of Plasmid Stability

Extra-chromosomal genetic elements are important drivers of bacterial evolution, and their evolutionary success depends on positive selection for the genes they encode. Examples are plasmids encoding antibiotic resistance genes that are maintained in the presence of antibiotics (e.g., [1–3]). Plasmid maintenance is considered a metabolic burden to the host [4]; hence, when the cost of plasmid carriage outweighs its benefit, plasmid-free segregants are expected to outcompete plasmid-carrying cells, eventually leading to plasmid loss [5–7]. Thus, in the absence of positive selection, plasmid survival hinges upon stable persistence in the population. The ubiquity of plasmids in nature suggests that plasmids having a negligible effect on host fitness may evolve stable inheritance and thus gain a long-term persistence in the population, also in the absence of positive selection [8]. Nonetheless, the transition of plasmids into stably inherited genetic elements remains understudied. Here, we show that positive selection for a plasmid-encoded gene interferes with the evolution of plasmid stability. Evolving plasmids under different selection regimes in Escherichia coli, we find that antibiotics led to plasmid amplification, resulting in plasmid instability. Thus, under positive selection, suboptimal solutions for plasmid stability were maintained in the population hindering long-term plasmid persistence. Indeed, a survey of Escherichia plasmids confirms that antibiotic resistance genes are rarely found on small plasmids. Our results show that a plasmid-mediated advantage for the host may manifest in reduced plasmid evolutionary success. Considering plasmids as autonomously evolving entities holds promise for understanding the factors that govern their evolution.